Home For Fiction – Blog

for thinking people

Patreon LogoPatreon

Spain

Review of The Shadow of the Wind

May 30, 2019

Some time ago, when I reviewed Michel Laub’s Diary of the Fall, I mentioned how sometimes all the ingredients can be there but the recipe is still a failure. Carlos Ruiz Zafón’s The Shadow of the Wind is somewhat similar, I’m afraid. All the ingredients are there, yes. It kinda works, and yet it doesn’t.

To be fair, I think Zafón’s novel works comparatively better. That is, one can still read it and somewhat enjoy it. However, The Shadow of the Wind aspires to be a Gothic tale. And to this Gothic fiction specialist, it comes off as a failed attempt.

the shadow of the wind review
There is a sustained attempt to present The Shadow of the Wind as a Gothic tale, taking advantage of the settings. But although all the checkboxes are ticked, something is amiss.
(more…)